Reviewed and updated: November 10, 2026

We would choose Miele CM 5310 Silence for a new bean-to-cup purchase rather than seek out the older CM 5300. Consider CM 5300 only when you can assess the actual machine’s condition, complete parts and service arrangements. Both appeal if you want automatic coffee and milk drinks, including two servings together. The main compromise is ownership effort: the modest water tank, milk pipework and removable brew unit all need your attention.
The older model is not automatically the wrong choice, but a familiar name is not enough to make it a good one. We would begin with what you need from a coffee machine now, then decide whether the particular CM 5300 offer supplies it. If you already own a working CM 5300 and like its drinks, the existence of CM 5310 does not by itself make replacement worthwhile.
Our starting point for a new Miele purchase is CM 5310
Its removable brew unit gives you direct access for cleaning, while the milk pipework and modest water tank still need regular attention. The dedicated milk flask is optional; the electrical version and milk accessories must suit the machine.
CM 5310 Silence combines a grinder, automatic brewing and milk preparation in one countertop appliance. You select the drink instead of filling and tamping a portafilter for each serving. We would choose that format if you enjoy whole-bean coffee but want the preparation handled inside the machine. The convenience is in making the drink, while filling and cleaning remain part of the purchase.
OneTouch for Two lets you prepare two suitable servings together. That is useful when two people usually want coffee at the same time, and it is a more relevant feature than an extensive menu you rarely use. It still draws from one bean container, so it is not a way to make two different coffees from two separate bean supplies.
The adjustable drink parameters let you change the amount of coffee, water and milk to suit your preferred serving. We would value those controls when the household has a settled favorite drink. They give you room to adapt the machine’s preparation, but they do not remove the need to choose coffee you enjoy or to maintain the parts that handle it.
CM 5300 remains a conditional older-machine purchase
Consider CM 5300 when its condition, complete parts and service arrangements are clear. It offers automatic coffee and milk drinks with OneTouch for Two, but an older machine’s history matters more than a familiar model name. With an older CM 5300, the machine’s condition, accessories and available support are part of the purchase decision.
CM 5300 also offers OneTouch for Two, a built-in grinder and automatic milk preparation. It has a single 200-gram bean container and a 1.3-liter water tank, matching the basic capacities that shape the newer CM 5310’s use. We would not buy the older model expecting a larger reservoir or a fundamentally different way to supply two coffees.
The important comparison is between the actual offers, not just their similar menus. For an older or previously owned CM 5300, confirm that the brew unit, milk pipework, water tank, tray and grounds container are present and fit correctly. An incomplete milk assembly can change a machine advertised for cappuccino into a purchase that still needs parts before it meets your needs.
We would also want a clear account of its condition and maintenance history, with support appropriate to the actual seller and machine. Do not assume that the arrangements for a new CM 5310 apply to an older CM 5300 offer. That is why we would begin a straightforward new purchase with CM 5310, while assessing an older machine individually.
The water tank matters more than the bean hopper looks
A 200-gram hopper can hold a useful supply of beans, but the 1.3-liter water tank sets a different limit. Water is used for drinks and prescribed rinsing, so dividing the full tank by your mug size overstates how many uninterrupted drinks to expect. We would choose this compact Miele arrangement for a modest household rather than expect a large-reservoir experience.
The coffee-pot function offers a way to prepare several servings, but it does not enlarge the tank. If you regularly serve a group, allow for filling water and emptying the used-coffee container as needed. Two-at-once preparation is convenient for a pair; it is not the same as a plumbed-in machine that can run without reservoir attention.
The body is about 9½ inches wide and 18⅛ inches deep. That depth deserves a place in your counter measurement, alongside working room for opening the service area and removing parts. We would not judge the fit only from a front photograph. You need to use the machine and clean it in that location, not simply place it there.
Milk convenience comes with a separate cleaning decision
CM 5310 uses milk pipework that can draw from a suitable milk container or carton. A dedicated Miele milk flask is optional, rather than an essential part of every setup. We would choose automatic milk preparation for cappuccinos and similar drinks when you are comfortable keeping that milk pathway clean.
The convenience is different from holding a jug under a manual steam wand: the machine handles the preparation through its pipework. In return, you have pipework and dispensing parts to rinse and clean according to the instructions. An automatic rinse helps with that care but does not mean that milk-contact components can be ignored afterward.
For a household that mostly drinks black coffee, those milk features may be less valuable. Our Jura E4 and E6 comparison separates a black-coffee machine from a cappuccino option. We would compare that simpler format if avoiding an attached milk system matters more than preparing two Miele milk drinks together.
A removable brew unit gives access, with work attached
CM 5310’s brew unit can be removed for cleaning. We would value that direct access if you prefer seeing and rinsing the component that handles the grounds. It also means accepting the prescribed removal and care, rather than expecting every task to happen through an automatic program. The benefit is accessible maintenance, not maintenance-free ownership.
The current CM 5310 instructions call for hand cleaning the brew unit with warm water and no cleaning agents; it must not go in the dishwasher. Some other removable components are dishwasher safe under specified temperature limits. We would follow the individual part instructions rather than assume that the broad ComfortClean description applies to everything.
Cleaning tablets, descaling care and milk-system supplies belong in the ownership plan as well. Follow the exact model’s instructions, including the permitted bean types. CM 5310’s manual excludes oily or treated beans, so an attractive flavored bag is not automatically suitable for its grinder. Those compatibility limits matter as much as the drink buttons.
Our recommendation
Choose CM 5310 Silence for a new Miele purchase when two-serving preparation and a removable brew unit fit your preferences. Consider CM 5300 only as a clearly assessed older-machine offer with complete parts and suitable support.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.