Mr. Coffee Café Grind Review: Cup Selector or a Direct Timer?

Reviewed and updated: November 10, 2026

Original editorial image for Mr. Coffee Burr Grinder Review: Current Alternatives and Checks (Updated 2026)

We recommend Café Grind BVMC-BMG25 if you want a straightforward electric burr grinder for a household pot of coffee and prefer a cup selector to setting a grinding time. Its removable hopper and grounds chamber make filling and emptying approachable. The compromise is that the cup setting is only a starting point for the amount of grounds, and repeated batches need cooling breaks. We’d choose OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder 8717000 if a remembered timer and stainless grounds cup better suit your counter.

The useful comparison is how you want to repeat your daily dose. Café Grind gives you separate controls for grind size and the number of marked cups. OXO asks you to choose a grinding time and remembers it for the next use. Neither control weighs the finished coffee, so the better choice depends on which adjustment feels simpler alongside your brewer.

The removable hopper helps with access, but the cup setting is an approximate dosing guide and the grinder needs cooling breaks between repeated batches.

For a simple cup-selector grinder for household batches

Mr. Coffee Café Grind — BVMC-BMG25

We recommend Café Grind when you want electric burr grinding with straightforward grind and cup selectors.

Find in Amazon (paid link)

Café Grind is a practical match for a regular household batch

The current Café Grind model uses flat burr plates and has 18 grind selections, with a separate selector covering two to eighteen marked cups. That lets you change the grind for your brewing method without deliberately changing the amount control at the same time. It is a more defined way to select a grind than deciding only how long to hold a blade grinder’s button.

The cup control is most useful when you normally make a similar pot and can settle on an amount that suits it. The manual’s coffee measurements use five-ounce cups, so an eighteen-cup label does not describe eighteen full travel mugs. It also does not mean the grinder brews anything: you transfer the grounds to your coffee maker after grinding.

More importantly, changing grind size changes how much coffee the same amount setting delivers. The manual explains that finer and coarser settings produce different output volumes. If you want a dependable measured dose, check the grounds with a coffee scale rather than assuming the selector is a built-in weighing system. Once you know your usual amount, the cup dial becomes a convenient repeat control.

The removable hopper holds up to eight ounces of beans. That is useful for several household brews, but it is not a reason to empty a large bag into the machine and leave it there indefinitely. If you switch between regular and decaf often, consider how much unused coffee you are leaving in the hopper and grinding path before deciding a larger bean supply is more convenient.

OXO makes more sense when you want to control time directly

We would choose OXO for a regular coffee station where you want to set the timer once and start the same timed grind with one press. It uses stainless conical burrs, fifteen main grind positions and additional intermediate adjustments. The different control arrangement is the main reason to consider it here; a larger number printed beside a competitor’s dial does not by itself prove better coffee.

We would choose the OXO when you prefer to set grinding time directly and repeat it with one press. Its conical burrs, intermediate adjustments and stainless catcher suit a regular filter-coffee station, but it is larger and its timer still does not weigh the dose. The timer-based OXO is a different grinder from the scale-equipped version.

For a remembered grinding time and a stainless grounds cup

OXO Brew Conical Burr Coffee Grinder 8717000

We recommend OXO when you want powered grinding and a grind-size dial for regular filter coffee.

Find in Amazon (paid link)

The stainless grounds container is another useful difference if you prefer that material to a plastic catcher. OXO describes it as static-fighting, but we would not promise a completely mess-free counter with every bean or room condition. You still remove the container and pour the grounds into a filter, and coffee can remain around the dispensing area.

Its hopper holds up to twelve ounces and has a trap door to help contain beans when the hopper is removed. That arrangement can be helpful when you need access for cleaning or want to change coffee. It does not mean the entire grinding path empties without any retained grounds, and its timer still needs adjusting when the coffee or grind setting changes.

Our OXO grinder review develops that timer-based choice for everyday filter coffee. We would pay attention to how easily you can repeat the amount you want, rather than treat flat versus conical burr geometry as a shortcut to a guaranteed flavor result in your kitchen.

Cooling and cleaning can change which grinder you want

Café Grind is intended for household use, with cooling breaks called for in its manual. Allow at least two minutes between grinding cycles, and follow the longer ten-minute rest after four batches. That is a meaningful limit if you want to grind several large quantities consecutively. For an ordinary morning pot it may be easy to accommodate; for repeated bulk preparation we would look beyond this small household machine.

The removable upper burr gives you access to the grinding area for brushing after the grinder is unplugged. The hopper and grounds chamber can be hand-washed and must be completely dry before reassembly. We would use that conservative care route rather than assume that every removable component, the burrs or the motor base can go in a dishwasher.

The lid and chamber also need to be properly seated for safe operation. If the machine does not run because a part is out of place, that is a reason to check assembly with the unit unplugged, not defeat an interlock. A grinder that comes apart for cleaning is helpful only if you can comfortably return those parts to their correct positions.

Both choices need a place where you can remove the catcher and reach the hopper without moving the machine during use. Café Grind is approximately 11.5 inches high, with a body about 8.2 inches long and 5.3 inches wide. OXO is taller at roughly 14.8 inches, so check the actual filling and cleaning clearance rather than comparing only the space occupied by the base.

We would make a different decision for an espresso-led setup

Café Grind’s range includes a fine setting marketed for espresso, but that description alone does not establish how well its adjustment steps will match your espresso machine and basket. A setup that needs very small grind changes deserves a grinder selected for that task. We would not buy this one on the assumption that the finest position guarantees a dialed-in shot.

The same qualification applies to treating OXO’s broad range as a universal espresso recommendation. Here we would choose between these two for filter-coffee convenience and the controls you prefer. If espresso is your main drink, identify the adjustment range and dosing arrangement your actual machine needs before committing to a general-purpose household grinder.

Our recommendation

Choose Café Grind BVMC-BMG25 for a straightforward cup-selector burr grinder and accept its approximate dosing and cooling requirements. Choose OXO 8717000 for a remembered timer, stainless catcher and different hopper handling. Earlier grinders from the same brands and OXO’s scale-equipped version are different products.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.